I’ve been using a wiki for many years, but a few years back I started feeling that it’s being “abandoned” and less relevant for me due to the limited support and design options.
First, while WordPress have developed their auto-upgrade tools into an elegant and smooth procedure, MediaWiki still hasn’t gotten further than me still having to manually download the zip-file, extract the zip-file, then upload the extracted files after which an in-place reinstallation can be done (although now at least even keeping the existing settings with no big problems). This isn’t really progress in the area of smooth installation, and since nothing much has happened for, what, 5 years maybe ? I doubt much will happen fast in the coming years.
Second, editing is quite tricky and I can never seem to remember all the special “codes” required for formatting. A better rich-text editor would have been lovely to have and as for help the MediaWiki source site itself remains very inaccessible, links go to outdated pages (like “skins”, more below), I really can’t find any decent support or help or ways of contacting someone for asking questions, and while free software comes with no obligation at least WordPress has a community and support forum.
Third and most important to me is the lack of themes, or “skins”. WordPress have developed an impressively large number of free and commercial themes to choose from. As for Wiki on the other hand, after extensive searches some 2 years back I managed to find a fan-based port of the Twenty Ten WordPress theme to WikiMedia, and while it had some bugs it at least made the wiki rather nice looking.
But now MediaWiki has moved one step further and categorized all the old skins as “outdated” and the rather limited number of currently supported official skins is laughably small and looking sadly poor in design.
Also illustrated by the fact that if I try to search on for example Google for “MediaWiki skins” the most recent links I get are the same as the ones I found in 2009 while then searching for the same, so it does not appear to be an area where there is any substantial amount of community development.
And so, as there from my point of view seems to be negative development in design and no real progress for me as a user in functionality I’m starting to think whether I should really spend any more energy on the wiki. While I do have quite a lot of articles stored there, I could either choose to use the time in trying to find some migration tools, or I could just “depromote” the wiki from being the main page into a sub-domain (though I guess that will be a little challenging in regards to links).
Or I could just let it die, as with the PHPBB forum from so many years ago, but that would be a shame considering the time spent on all the content, so the migration feels like the better path.